Kelleys Island Hotels: Your Guide to Comfort

kelleys island hotels
kelleys island hotels


Welcome to Kelleys Island, located on Lake Erie. Kelleys Island is a great destination for couples, families, and friends. With its relaxed atmosphere and endless attractions, there is something for everyone on the island. Whether you like wine tasting, fishing, boating, hiking, or camping. In this guide we will walk you through everything you need to know about Kelleys Island hotels, ensuring a great stay on the island.

Overview of Kelleys Island

Once inhabited by indigenous people and then being a part of the War of 1812, it is now a part of the United States. The island played a key part in the war and that shaped what the island has become today. There is a rich history behind the island such as glaciers, war, and civilizations. The island has a unique shape and has many rocky shoals on its shores. Surrounded by other islands, Kelleys remains one of the top vacation spots on Lake Erie.

Kelleys Island isn’t your typical tourist destination. It’s a relaxing island located in the freshwater of Lake Erie. Families, friends, and couples vacation on the island for a relaxing getaway. The island only has about 250 full-time residences, but thousands of people visit each year on vacation.

Types of Kelleys Island Hotels

When it comes to accommodations, Kelleys Island offers something for every taste and budget. Whether you’re looking for a primitive vacation or the most exquisite resort on the island, there is a hotel for you. Hotel options on the island come in all price ranges so you can plan your vacation accordingly. Some travelers prefer private settings and there are hotels on Kelleys Island that give you just that.

Luxury Resorts and Boutique Hotels

For travelers who prefer luxury, Kelleys Island Ohio has upscale resorts and boutique hotels that promise a good experience. Be sure to research the hotels with specific amenities you are interested in. There are different options on the island. During my stay at the charming Kelleys Island Venture Resort, I was treated to breathtaking lake views, impeccable service, and luxurious amenities that made me feel like royalty.

Cozy Bed and Breakfasts

If you’re seeking a more intimate stay, Kelleys Island’s cozy bed and breakfasts are sure to delight. Bed and breakfasts offer an affordable alternative to small hotel rooms. I recall my stay at the Water’s Edge Retreat, where warm hospitality, homemade breakfasts, and decorations made me feel right at home. They have a relaxing deck attached to the house which offers views of Lake Erie and the main road through the island.

Budget-Friendly Motels and Inns

Traveling on a budget? No problem! Kelleys Island Ohio offers a variety of budget-friendly motels and inns that provide comfort without costing a fortune. During my backpacking adventure, I found comfort at the Inn on Kelleys Island, where friendly staff, clean rooms, and affordable rates made my stay stress-free. The inn is located on the south shore on the main road facing the water. The view is spectacular.

Campgrounds and RV Parks

For outdoor enthusiasts, Kelleys Island features a campground and RV park on the island. Whether you’re pitching a tent or parking your RV, you’ll wake up to stunning views and endless adventures right at your doorstep. Kelleys Island State Park is a full-service camping destination on the island.

They offer all types of campsites. There are activities for all ages and types of people in the park. There are hiking trails, fishing opportunities, and group activities available. If you are looking for a more DIY stay on Kelleys Island, the State Park is an excellent option.

Top Picks for Every Traveler

With so many options to choose from, finding the perfect hotel can be overwhelming. To simplify your search, here are my top picks tailored to different types of travelers:

Family Vacation to Kelleys Island

For families traveling with children, I highly recommend Kelley’s Island Venture Resort. With spacious accommodations, family-friendly amenities, and convenient access to the island’s attractions, it’s the perfect home base for creating cherished memories together. They have an onsite pool and are within walking distance of many attractions. The resort has clean rooms and friendly staff available at all hours to help you with anything you might need.

Kelleys island stay

A Couple’s Getaway on Kelleys Island

Planning a romantic getaway? Look no further than the charming Paradise Cottage. Nestled amidst lush greenery and overlooking Lake Erie, this intimate retreat offers cozy rooms, scenic views, and a serene ambiance that’s perfect for rekindling romance. It is a small cottage built just right for two people. The cottage offers the privacy that couples expect when on vacation. The staff is friendly and available when you need them.

Kelleys Island Hotels for Single Adventurers

As a solo traveler myself, I understand the importance of finding a safe and welcoming haven. That’s why I recommend the Kelleys Island Venture Resort. With its friendly staff, communal atmosphere, and convenient location, it’s the ideal place to connect with fellow adventurers and embark on solo explorations. Their property offers easy in and out for me to go sight see on the island. Single rooms are easy to book.

Traveling with Friends

Traveling with friends? Any of the private houses for rent are the perfect choice for group getaways. Usually, groups coming to the island are fishermen. Make sure you pick a house that has ample parking such as Kelleys Cozy Corner. Most home rentals will accommodate trailers. Kelleys Island has a public boat ramp on the North side of the island as well as a couple of private boat ramps on the South side for your needs. Your host can point you in the right direction when you arrive.

Insider Tips for Booking

Now that you’ve narrowed down your options, it’s time to book your stay. Here are some insider tips to ensure a smooth and enjoyable experience:

Best Time to Visit Kelleys Island

visiing kelleys island

Kelleys Island experiences peak tourist seasons during the summer months, so be sure to book your accommodations well in advance if you’re planning a summer getaway. For a quieter experience, consider visiting during the shoulder seasons of spring or fall when the weather is still pleasant, and the crowds are thinner. Fishermen and birdwatchers typically stay on the island in the fall and spring, outside of peak season. Typically the Kelleys Island ferry runs late in the season until the ice on Lake Erie forms.

Finding Deals and Discounts

Keep an eye out for special promotions and discounts offered by hotels throughout the year. Many accommodations offer seasonal deals, package discounts, or last-minute specials that can help you save money on your stay. If you are a veteran or first responder, check with the hotel to see if they offer a discount. Other discounts may apply for off-season stays as well. During the off-season, special rates are available and you can save hundreds on your stay.

Booking in Advance

To secure your preferred accommodations and avoid disappointment, it’s recommended to book your stay as early as possible, especially during peak travel times. Kelleys Island hotels book up fast pre-summer. By planning, you’ll have peace of mind knowing that your lodging is confirmed, allowing you to focus on enjoying your island adventure.

Transportation and Proximity

Consider the location of your chosen hotel keeping Kelleys Island’s attractions and amenities in mind. If you’re relying on public transportation or prefer to explore on foot, opt for accommodations within walking distance of key sites. Alternatively, if you’re bringing a vehicle or renting a golf cart, proximity may be less of a concern. Bicycles are another option for transportation, you can bring one or rent one. If you bring a boat to the island, which a lot of people do, make sure you are near the marina or boat ramp you will be using.

caddy shack square

Making the Most of Your Hotel Stay

Your hotel is more than just a place to sleep—it’s your home away from home during your Kelleys Island adventure. Here are some tips for maximizing your enjoyment during your stay:

Utilizing On-Site Hotel Amenities

Take advantage of the amenities offered by your hotel, whether it’s a refreshing dip in the pool, a relaxing spa treatment, or a delicious meal at the on-site restaurant. These extras can enhance your overall experience and make your stay even more memorable. Some hotels even offer room service if that’s what you like. If you require specific amenities for your stay, communicate that to the host before your stay.

Engaging with Local Staff

The staff at your hotel are invaluable resources for insider tips and recommendations. Don’t hesitate to strike up a conversation with them—they’re locals who know the island inside and out and can provide valuable insights on hidden gems, must-see attractions, and off-the-beaten-path experiences. Most of the hotels on the island have had the same owners for years, they know what is best and will take care of you.

Exploring Kelleys Island

While your hotel may offer all the comforts of home, don’t forget to venture out and explore everything Kelleys Island has to offer. Whether it’s hiking through scenic trails, kayaking along the shoreline, or discovering historical landmarks, the island is brimming with adventure waiting to be discovered.

Choosing the right hotel is the key to unlocking a truly memorable Kelleys Island experience. Whether you’re seeking luxury, charm, affordability, or adventure, the island offers a diverse array of accommodations to suit every traveler’s needs. By following the tips and recommendations in this guide, you’ll be well-equipped to find the perfect hotel and make the most of your island getaway. So pack your bags, book your stay, and get ready to embark on an unforgettable journey to Kelleys Island!