Best Restaurants on South Bass Island

Put-in-Bay Restaurants
Put-in-Bay Restaurants

South Bass Island offers a unique island experience when visiting the bars and restaurants. Some offer water views where you can watch the marina, boats, and other islands in the distance. Some establishments will serve bar food such as burgers, melts, and wings. Other establishments have bars, but serve a more diverse cuisine such as steak, seafood, and wine. Whether you are with your family, a couple, or you live on the island, there is a restaurant that serves what you like. Expect to pay a little more than you would on the mainland for dining on South Bass Island. The food served arrives by boat or plane. Below are the best restaurants on South Bass Island.

South Bass Island: Best Restaurants

The Boardwalk

The Boardwalk is a beloved dining destination on the island, offering a variety of seafood and waterfront dining experiences. With multiple restaurants under one roof, you can enjoy fresh Lake Erie perch, lobster bisque, and other seafood delights while overlooking the marina. It’s a great place to have a meal while watching the boats go by. They have a full-service bar that can make your favorite cocktail. The boardwalk is a fan favorite on the island.

The Keys

The Keys offers a unique tropical atmosphere and is known for its delicious Caribbean-inspired cuisine. You can enjoy dishes like jerk chicken, conch fritters, and fresh seafood in a laid-back, beachy setting. Live music often adds to the vibrant atmosphere, making it a memorable dining experience.

Hooligans Irish Pub

For a taste of Irish fare and a friendly atmosphere, Hooligans Irish Pub is a popular choice. The menu includes classic Irish dishes such as fish and chips, shepherd’s pie, and corned beef sandwiches. It’s a great spot for a casual meal and a pint of your favorite brew.

hooligans irish pub south bass island

Goat Soup & Whiskey

This cozy and eclectic restaurant offers a diverse menu with options ranging from sandwiches and burgers to international dishes. The relaxed ambiance and unique decor make Goat Soup & Whiskey a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

The Forge

The Forge offers a fine dining experience on South Bass Island. It’s known for its upscale menu featuring steaks, seafood, and a carefully curated wine list. With an elegant and romantic atmosphere, The Forge is an excellent choice for a special occasion or a romantic dinner.

Pasquale’s Cafe

Pasquale’s Cafe is a charming Italian restaurant known for its delicious pizzas, pastas, and homemade sauces. It’s a family-friendly place where you can enjoy a taste of Italy right on the island.

Frosty Bar

Frosty Bar is a classic American diner and a local institution. You can savor burgers, sandwiches, and breakfast items in a nostalgic setting. It’s a great spot for a casual and affordable meal.


Mossbacks is a waterfront restaurant offering a diverse menu with options for everyone in the family. From seafood and steaks to sandwiches and salads, there’s something for every palate. The outdoor patio provides beautiful views of the harbor.

Topsy Turvey’s

Topsy Turvey’s is known for its casual and laid-back atmosphere. It offers a menu featuring burgers, sandwiches, and bar favorites. The rooftop deck is a popular spot to enjoy a meal with a view.

Joe’s Bar and Restaurant

Joe’s Bar and Restaurant is a local hangout with a friendly atmosphere. It offers a menu of American classics like burgers, sandwiches, and wings. It’s a great place to relax and enjoy a meal with family or friends.

In conclusion, South Bass Island offers a wide range of dining options to suit various tastes and preferences. Almost all the bars and restaurants are located downtown and easily accessible by golf cart, bicycle, or walking from your hotel. Whether you’re in the mood for seafood, international cuisine, casual dining, or upscale experiences, you’ll find something to satisfy your palate on this island in Lake Erie.