3 Best Put-in-Bay Villas to Book

put-in-bay villas

Are you traveling to Put-in-Bay this summer? Do you need a place to stay? Check out our list of the Top 3 Put-in-Bay Villas that you need to check out. They are great places to stay with plenty of ammenities. They are close to downtown and will accomodate anyone!

Overview of the Best Put-in-Bay Villas

Villa NameLocationNotable FeaturesBest For
Bay Lodging ResortQuiet area, close to downtownIndoor/outdoor pools, pet-friendly, free breakfastFamilies, pet owners
Bayshore ResortWaterfrontLake views, luxury amenities, on-site diningCouples, honeymooners
Harriet’s HouseNear downtownHistoric charm, boutique feel, multiple lodging optionsFamilies, history lovers

Why Stay in Put-in-Bay Villas?

Many visitors opt for traditional hotels or rental homes, but staying in a villa provides several advantages:

  • More space – Villas offer multiple bedrooms, living areas, and kitchens, making them ideal for families and groups.
  • Privacy – Unlike hotels, villas provide a quieter, more exclusive environment.
  • Amenities – Many Put-in-Bay villas feature pools, outdoor spaces, and modern appliances.
  • Cost efficiency – Booking a villa can be more economical than multiple hotel rooms for large groups.
  • Convenient locations – Villas often sit near major attractions while offering a peaceful retreat.

With these benefits in mind, let’s explore the best Put-in-Bay villas to consider for your stay.

1. Bay Lodging Resort

Location and Accessibility

Bay Lodging Resort is located in a quiet area just a short walk from downtown Put-in-Bay. This location provides easy access to the island’s shops, restaurants, and nightlife while offering a peaceful atmosphere away from the busiest parts of town.

Guests can rent golf carts, bikes, or take shuttle services to navigate the island conveniently.

Amenities and Features

Bay Lodging Resort blends modern comforts with a relaxed island vibe. Notable amenities include:

  • Indoor and outdoor pools, allowing guests to swim in any weather.
  • Complimentary breakfast, providing a convenient meal before heading out for the day.
  • Pet-friendly accommodations, making it easy to bring a furry companion.
  • Spacious villas featuring multiple bedrooms, full kitchens, and comfortable living areas.

Who Should Stay Here

Bay Lodging Resort is ideal for:

  • Families needing extra space and kid-friendly amenities.
  • Couples looking for a quiet retreat near downtown.
  • Pet owners who want to bring their dogs along.

Booking Information and Pricing

  • Best time to book is early spring for summer stays.
  • Rates vary with peak season prices from June to August.
  • Booking directly through their website may offer special discounts.

2. Bayshore Resort

Location and Scenic Views

Bayshore Resort is one of the few Put-in-Bay villas that offers direct lakefront views. Guests can wake up to sunrises over Lake Erie and enjoy a peaceful setting away from the island crowds.

Luxury Amenities and Features

Bayshore Resort provides an upscale experience with:

  • Two heated swimming pools that offer relaxation and fun.
  • Private balconies with stunning lakefront views.
  • On-site dining and bar so guests can enjoy great food without leaving the resort.
  • Modern villa suites featuring elegant decor, full kitchens, and spacious layouts.

Who Should Stay at Put-in-Bay Villas?

This resort is best for:

  • Couples seeking a romantic getaway.
  • Honeymooners looking for luxury and privacy.
  • Visitors who prioritize scenic views and high-end amenities.

Booking Information and Pricing

  • These villas book up quickly, so reservations should be made months in advance.
  • Seasonal pricing is highest in summer, with discounts available in early fall.
  • Mid-week specials can provide savings during peak months.

3. Harriet’s House

Location and Proximity to Attractions

Harriet’s House is located near downtown Put-in-Bay, providing easy access to local attractions, restaurants, and shops. Visitors can walk to Perry’s Victory Monument and enjoy the island’s lively atmosphere. You can always rent a golf cart on Put-in-Bay for your whole stay.

Unique Features of This Put-in-Bay Villa

Harriet’s House offers a boutique lodging experience with:

  • Family-run hospitality that provides personalized service.
  • A variety of lodging options, including villas, cottages, and private suites.
  • An outdoor pool and gathering areas that are ideal for families and groups.
  • A charming blend of historic character and modern conveniences.

Who Should Stay Here

  • Families looking for a warm, home-like stay.
  • History lovers who appreciate unique accommodations.
  • Groups needing multiple lodging options in one location.

Booking Information and Pricing

  • Booking early is essential, as Harriet’s House has limited availability.
  • The best value months are May and September when rates are lower.
  • Direct booking often includes flexible cancellation policies.

How to Choose the Right Put-in-Bay Villas for Your Trip

Selecting the best villa depends on several factors.

  • Budget – Bayshore Resort is the most luxurious, while Bay Lodging Resort offers budget-friendly options.
  • Group Size – Harriet’s House and Bay Lodging Resort are ideal for families and large groups.
  • Desired Atmosphere – Bayshore Resort is perfect for relaxation, while Harriet’s House provides a more social, boutique-style experience.

Hopefully, you found a place to stay with our 3 best Put-in-Bay Villas to book. Remember, there are more choices than what is listed. However, these are top picks on the island!