Discovering the Best Put-in-Bay Stores

Are you visiting Put-in-Bay this summer? Check out these 5 stores you need to visit while staying on Put-in-Bay!

Summary of the top 5 stores to visit on Put-in-Bay

Store Name	Specialty	Unique Features	Why Visit?

The Country House

Home décor, gifts, island-themed souvenirs

Nautical decorations, Put-in-Bay-branded pottery

Personal service, unique island charm, great gift options

The Carriage House

Island-themed apparel and memorabilia

Extensive clothing range, limited-edition souvenirs

Affordable, high-quality island souvenirs for all ages

Frosty Gifts

Frosty Bar-branded merchandise

Retro-themed glassware, T-shirts, and accessories

Nostalgic appeal, ideal for collectors and bar enthusiasts

Jessie’s Jewelry

Handcrafted, custom-designed jewelry

Artisan craftsmanship, premium materials, custom designs

Unique keepsakes, personalized service, timeless pieces

PIB Candy Bar

Retro candies, handmade chocolates, sweets

Family-friendly atmosphere, wide candy selection

Fun, nostalgic shopping experience with treats for all ages

Why Shop at Put-in-Bay?

The Unique Island Shopping Experience

Shopping at Put-in-Bay is unlike anywhere else. While out enjoying the activities on Put-in-Bay, you might as well stop at some of the local stores. Here, shopping feels personal—store owners often greet you by name, and many products are locally sourced or handmade. Whether you’re hunting for artisan jewelry, custom clothing, or quirky souvenirs, these stores reflect the island’s vibrant culture and hospitality.

Supporting Local Businesses

Shopping locally isn’t just a trend—it’s a way to support Put-in-Bay’s thriving economy. Many stores on the island are family-run, and each purchase helps sustain these businesses. Plus, buying local often means getting higher quality, handcrafted items that hold sentimental value. When you shop at Put-in-Bay, you are helping the locals. They only get visitors during the warm months in Ohio. Every dollar helps these local places!

Top 5 Put-in-Bay Stores for Unforgettable Shopping

1. The Country House

One of Put-in-Bay’s most iconic stores, The Country House is a treasure trove of home décor, unique gifts, and island-themed souvenirs. Established over two decades ago, it has become a staple for tourists seeking something special. From nautical-themed decorations to quirky kitchenware, you’ll find products that embody the charm of island living.

Why Shop Here?

Unique Finds: Items exclusive to the store, like Put-in-Bay-branded pottery.
Personalized Service: Friendly staff who offer gift-wrapping and tailored recommendations.
Great Atmosphere: Relaxing ambiance that makes browsing enjoyable.

2. The Carriage House

For anyone obsessed with Put-in-Bay memorabilia, The Carriage House is the ultimate destination. Known for its wide selection of island-themed merchandise, this store offers everything from T-shirts and hats to mugs and magnets. If you’re looking for a memento that screams “I’ve been to Put-in-Bay,” you’ll find it here.

Highlights:

Extensive Apparel Range: High-quality, comfortable clothing for all ages.
Exclusive Souvenirs: Limited-edition items you won’t find anywhere else.
Affordable Pricing: Budget-friendly without sacrificing quality.

3. Frosty Gifts

Part of the beloved Frosty Bar brand, Frosty Gifts offers an array of branded merchandise that’s perfect for fans of the iconic bar. Known for its retro vibe, this store carries glassware, T-shirts, and accessories that make great gifts or collectibles.

Why Visit Frosty Gifts?

Nostalgic Appeal: Perfect for visitors who want to bring home a piece of Put-in-Bay history.
High-Quality Merchandise: Durable clothing and accessories that last.
Exclusive Frosty Branding: Ideal for bar enthusiasts and collectors.

4. Jessie’s Jewelry

Looking for a personalized keepsake? Jessie’s Jewelry specializes in handcrafted, custom-designed jewelry. From sterling silver bracelets to gemstone earrings, their pieces are as unique as the island itself. Jessie’s Jewelry offers visitors the chance to purchase a meaningful, timeless souvenir.

What Sets Them Apart?

Artisan Craftsmanship: Every piece is handmade with meticulous attention to detail.
Custom Designs: Work directly with jewelers to create something special.
High-Quality Materials: Only premium metals and stones are used.

5. PIB Candy Bar

A trip to PIB Candy Bar isn’t just shopping—it’s a walk down memory lane. This candy store is stocked with retro treats, handmade chocolates, and novelty sweets that appeal to kids and adults alike.

Top Reasons to Visit:

Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Great spot for kids and those with a sweet tooth.
Wide Candy Selection: From vintage classics to modern favorites.
Memorable Experience: Fun, nostalgic vibes that make it a must-visit.

Additional Must-Visit Put-in-Bay Stores

Unique Boutiques and Gift Shops

Beyond the top five stores, Put-in-Bay offers a variety of boutiques and gift shops that cater to different tastes. Whether you’re into fashion, handmade crafts, or quirky finds, these stores offer a refreshing change from typical shopping centers.

Island Style Boutique: Known for its trendy clothing and accessories.
Local Craft Shops: Featuring handmade pottery, woven goods, and artisan candles.

Art Galleries and Craft Stores

For art lovers, Put-in-Bay’s art galleries and craft stores are a dream come true. You’ll find local artists displaying paintings, sculptures, and handmade crafts that capture the essence of island life.

What to Buy at Put-in-Bay Stores

Category	Popular Items	Why Buy?
Souvenirs	Keychains, postcards, T-shirts	Affordable, memorable gifts for family and friends.
Handmade Goods	Jewelry, ceramics, décor	Unique, locally crafted pieces with lasting value.
Food Products	Island wines, jams, chocolates	Taste the island with every bite or sip.